Giving Advice
September 29th, 2007
Today I had a lesson in giving advice, and why it is almost never advisable. (Ha!) In conversation with a dear friend, I found myself beaking off with all manner of advice and opinions and interpretations, which were entirely unsolicited, and rather unwelcome. I do know better than this – lesson one at therapy school is never give advice. (Except things like “You should have a doctor look at that,” or “No, you should not abuse others” and so on.) But I fell into it and of course the conversation ended tensely.
I’m not a total jerk – I did call up later to apologize for being so insensitive. And have resolved anew to hold my tongue unless a request is received to do otherwise. Because here is something else I have learned: when people come to you to talk about problems, they almost never want your advice. Not really. They want to vent. They want to feel heard, supported, and cared for. They almost always know what they’re going to do already, and even if they do outright ask for advice (a rare event indeed!), they generally do so only as a way to confirm their pre-existing decision, either by accepting your congruent advice or devising ways of shooting contradictory advice down.
Asking for advice is, in most instances, a form of social stroke exchange entirely divorced from the literal meaning of advice seeking. And anyway, if the other person really doesn’t know what to do, and really wants your advice, you should run like fuck away from that trap. One, you don’t want to be responsible for a course of action when you have imperfect knowledge of the situation which, trust me, you do. And two, it’s creepy for someone else to totally abdicate responsibility for themselves to you and you just shouldn’t go there. (Disclosure: I occasionally force Husband to offer advice when I’m stumped, though of course he hates this and I ignore his advice anyway.)
Hey, did you notice how I totally gave advice up there? Oh, I kill me. I just can’t escape being a know it all. Oh well… if ever there was a place to be obnoxious, it’s on a blog.
