Be amazed, gentle readers: I have concocted a vegan pho that tastes great! This is the culmination of two years of experimentation, and I’m so pleased I could just pop. Giving up pho was one of the tougher sacrifices to veganism, and it remains a chief temptation when I’m hungry and anywhere on the east side of the city. For those not in the know, pho is Vietnamese beef noodle soup - it’s glorious and wonderful and I’d marry it if I didn’t already have Husband. So how did I do it, when pho is all about the beef broth and I don’t eat cows? The answer is simple. To borrow a phrase from marketing, I have taken advantage of better living through chemistry.

I bought this at Safeway. McCormick’s also makes faux chicken broth and a vegetable broth which I assume is real. I’m not sure if you can read the tiny writing under “Beef” but what it says is: “style:” beef style. But does it taste any good? Well, as a former meat eater, I have to tell you that plain and naked as a clear broth, no. It’s not quite right, if you know what I mean. Beef style, not beef. There is also a certain undeniable chemical taste that gets in the way of truly fooling yourself into thinking you’re drinking the aftereffects of boiling cow meat and bones. Do recall I didn’t quit meat eating for aesthetic reasons!
So while this broth is great in places where broth itself is not the star (as a simmering liquid for veggies, or a boost to a chili, etc.), it really can’t cut it for pho. Without a little help. Let’s help it, shall we?
Begin with 10 cups of water and 5.5 cubes of the fake beef broth in a pot. According to the good people at McCormick’s we should only have five cubes for that volume of water, but I find it just wasn’t quite enough. Another half cube is perfect.
After consulting my little library of cook books, I decided to add also 1 generous tablespoon of tamari, and here’s the genius part: the stems of 10 or 12 mushrooms. I used creminis. Sounds simple but I tell you, the addition of these two ingredients goes miles towards hiding the unpleasant parts of the broth flavour while adding their own deliciousess. They are also in keeping with traditional pho recipes. And the mushroom caps? They will take the place of the beef in the final soup. No waste!

I already put the stems in the pot when I took this picture. Hang on to those caps for now.
Get the pot to a good simmer and make sure the cubes are all dissolved. They are bound with a little oil and in my opinion this helps with the simulation effect, since pho itself inevitably has some of the fat from the beef in it. Now we have some things to add to the broth. Here they are:

One onion, peeled and quartered. You should use a white one, which I actually did, but since I only bought one I had to use a ringer for the after-the-fact picture.
2 or 3 whole cloves, crushed (use a heavy pot or measuring cup and squash the cloves against your cutting board)
A 2 inch piece of fresh ginger, sliced into 8 or 10 rings. No need to peel.
2 teaspoons sugar
A 2 inch piece of cinnamon, broken up into pieces the same way you did the cloves
A scant teaspoon of anise seeds, also crushed
Now you just let it all simmer together for twenty or so minutes with the lid on. So easy! So pho-like! So vegan! There’s just one final addition to the broth: a teaspoon of peppercorns, crushed, added for only a minute at the end of the 20 minutes. If you cook pepper for a long time it becomes bitter and that’s yucky, so always add pepper at the end of your cooking. When the pepper is done, strain the broth through a seive and toss out the solid matter. What you are left with is gloriously dark, rich pho broth that is beefy and tastes like fresh, not chemical:

Pretend my stove is clean.
At this point you’ll add the mushroom caps chopped up any way you like (I think slices look nice and they cook fast too) to the broth, which you can leave simmering gently while you prepare the noodles (though you must balance your desire for cooked mushrooms with your desire to protect the pepper from bittering. It’s a judgment call.). Use rice noodles, which will have instructions on the package, and will be simple boil in water affairs. And then all we have left is assembly.
In large bowls, put a generous helping of noodles (strained) into the bottom. Pour broth over to cover the noodles. Put bowls on table and enjoy the smells. Provide the following as garnishes, which your appreciative family or guests will add according to their tastes:

Fresh basil
Bean sprouts
Green onion sliced on an angle
Sriracha sauce (called hot cock sauce in this house)
Hoisin sauce
Wedges of lime
Personally, I don’t like too much sweet in my savoury so I go light on the hoisin (though I go heavy on the hot sauce!). But I won’t judge you if you’re like Husband and want everything to be sweet. Make sure you provide enough of the veggies so people can really pile ‘em on - go nuts, it’s vegan. Eat with a combination of chop sticks and a big spoon so you can get noodles and broth in every bite!
And what happened to our friend the beef style broth? Through the alchemy of the additions during broth making, and the sauces you add at the table, it has been magically transformed into something that tastes fresh and homemade and beefy, but is entirely vegetable in nature. Okay, vegetable and chemical. We’re not perfect here.
Edit: It’s best if you only use 2 or 3 of the mushroom caps to finish the soup, otherwise the broth tastes too much like mushrooms, hiding the beefiness.
Edit 2: Husband would like me to tell you it’s called hot cock sauce because there is a rooster on it and it’s spicy, not because of anything indecent. He would also like me to stop writing about my bowel movements, which I won’t, but I will (hereby) formally register his complaint.